Flushed down the toilet, bagged and left for disposal; these are the fates that wait for us all, the possessions that once marked our lives seen finally as impositions to be packed away in dusty boxes marked – if we are lucky – ‘Dad’. “You’ll be able to go home” …
A Separation
Posted on December 22, 2011 by Paul
Our window into this doesn’t even have a name.
What he does have is Alzheimer’s, and all that it brings. The film’s opening sequence captures his son, Nader, sitting with wife Simin. She has come for a divorce. In Iran, both parties must agree before such a dissolution can be granted. The camera takes the perspective of an unseen judge, before whom the couple – not for the last time – are called to defend themselves. Simin pleads with the camera to be allowed to leave the country; ‘the situation’ isn’t good for their young daughter, she sobs. Nader looks resigned, saying only that he must stay behind to look after his ailing father.
Finding themselves at such an impasse, Simin goes to stay with family while her husband is left to care for their daughter, Tehmeh. Nader arranges for a carer to come in and help with his father while he is at work. The woman is from one of the poorer, more religious areas of the country, and seems unbearably anxious even before she has begun. On her first day, Razieh finds the elderly man soiled, staring vacantly at the floor. Offering a towel does no good, since it is apparent washing is now utterly beyond him. Overcome with guilt, she phones a religious scholar and wonders whether it is more of a sin to clean this man than to leave him as he is.
The politics and strange customs of religion are but one theme in a rich tapestry. This is not an especially polemic film, which is perhaps just as well. Asghar Farhadi has instead made a more universal picture, tempering its controversies with a story that centres on domestic estrangement. When Razieh reluctantly returns to the house the following day, she does so without the knowledge or consent of her husband, which becomes important consideration when a violent argument lands her in hospital. The authority this time is a local police chief, who presides with ever-decreasing patience over a case that sees Nader facing jail and Razieh struggling to keep her threadbare story from coming apart.
Amongst the recriminations and counterarguments, we return time and again to Termeh and her grandfather. Alzheimer’s is a uniquely dehumanising sentence which seems to render its victims as leaden-props to be moved into position. He is without words, yet his observance of the house speaks loudly in their absence. Save for his son, those around him often treat his care as little more than an afterthought, with directions to ‘keep watch’ often ignored to the point of cruel sport. Such flippancy leads to situations most helpless; the elderly man wedged behind a door someplace or, just once, tied to a bedpost while his carer runs errands. When he subsequently falls face first onto the floor, he must remain there until his son arrives home early from work.
Termeh, on the other hand, has words and uses them judiciously. She remains a quiet and well-mannered child, who grows suspicious of her father’s story. She, too, is an authority figure of sorts, yet A Separation is not her judgemental account, nor anyone elses. No one acts unreasonably, as if motivated by the whims of drama. We understand their choices and are able to sympathise with them in a way that defeats so many other films. It would have been easy in the circumstances – perhaps not unfairly – to paint Nader as the villain of the piece, just as Simin could well have been a beaten-down, eastern stereotype: the eternally sorrowful wife, refused her freedom by a callous husband and the justice system that enables him.
Neither is the case, and A Separation is especially involving for that. There are no easy solutions to be found, cultural or otherwise, yet this Iranian drama remains inescapably contemporary, whatever the larger theatre.
Twitter Updates
- RT @Slate: A wonderful letter Ronald Reagan sent to his son before his wedding: http://t.co/rxRoBfn6 via @LettersOfNote 4 days ago
- @laurenlaverne Not only do you schedule your show, but Breaking Bad hasn't been 'cancelled' so much as simply ending next year #sortofbetter 5 days ago
- Fun series from @rookiemag Ask a grown man: Jon Hamm http://t.co/7f8drQiE , BJ Novak http://t.co/5xw4ZLDr & Paul Rudd http://t.co/lx2zkbrZ 5 days ago
Categories
Submarine: Film of the Year 2011
Posted on December 9, 2011
In the largely subjective realm of film criticism, there can be few more useful barometers of quality than whether you were moved to again return to a film once your review had been filed. The process by which a critic arrives at their film of the year may be a …
Trespass
Posted on November 29, 2011
Kyle Miller lives in what I imagine was once an Art Deco installation, and does so while looking intriguingly like a cleaned-up Raoul Duke. Even for one of Nicolas Cage’s latter-day exercises in expressionism, that makes for a strange combination. His place in this far-fetched siege drama is to appear …
Waiting for Forever
Posted on May 11, 2011
Will Donner describes life as “starting out with goodness so pure and clear you won’t even know it’s there, because that’s the way it is when you don’t know anything”. The same could be said of cinema: limitless possibility projected out into the theatre before a film becomes what it …
Archives
Copyright 2012 Call Me Shallow - All Rights Reserved
Site Design by: Press75.com | Powered by: WordPress



